Posted by Indellethis on August 22, 2000 at 12:24:51:
In Reply to: Oh come on. (My rebuttal) posted by TSM on August 22, 2000 at 12:15:44:
> > In response to the first part, I hope (I don't know for sure) that no one gets that excited about a meaningless pk like this, especially when it goes against their rp.
>
> Meaningless on who's part? yours? Or his? I see him having lots of reason to attack you.
I'm saying that it wasn't like I killed Zorszaul or something, its not something to get very excited about. (Even though it probably doubles my pk record)
> > As for the Honor part. Attacking people while they are fighting others generally isn't considered very honorable.
>
> Its called defending what he believes in. He was an arbiter lord in the past, he will want to defend the hall when it is attacked. If you saw him fighting the massive giant or the destructor, you think an Honerable rager would say "Oh well..hes already fighting, I better leave him be." Like hell.
>
> You are putting up quite a weak arguement for why he has no honor. Perhaps you would like to give some more reasons that would actually apply.
I never knew he was an Arbiter Lord in the past, but that doesn't really change anything. It is not honorable to attack people while they are fighting others, it doesn't matter if they are raiding or not. Ragers, however, do attack people that are fighting the massive giant or Destructor because defense of the cabal is more important than honor at that point. Its the 7th commandment (I think).
If I had known he was an Arbiter Lord I wouldn't have made such a big deal about him accusing me of having no honor, but in my opinion it is never honorable to attack others while they are fighting.