McFadden is the most dynamic NFL-type player in college football with the exception of Glen Dorsey (LSU DT who is a fucking monster), but he shouldn't and won't win.

Chase Daniel is actually less deserving of being a finalist than a player like Dennis Dixon or Pat White (players whose teams looked horrible in games they didn't play(and cost both teams a shot at the National Title), Pat White got hurt and didn't play the second half of the South Florida game and dislocated his thumb in the 2nd Quarter of the Pitt game remember).

I think everyone is overlooking Colt Brennan. This is a guy when the spotlight was the brightest performed at his highest level. He set the NCAA (Division One, or BCS division, or whatever the fuck it's called now)records for passing yards (total), and passing TDs. With 10$million on the line, he brought Hawaii back from a 21 point deficit going 42-50 for 400 yard and 5 TDs. He even missed a few games! What will kill him is: A)Hawaii actually played fairly well WITHOUT him in a couple games he got dinged up...not good B)He plays for Hawaii C)He plays for Hawaii. He will not win.

Which leads us to Tebow. His year was amazing. I don't necessarily think he was the MVP of College Football this year.