Daevryn answered in a way that make it seem maledicts do work on mobs. Although mobs likely have higher stats than a player character of the same race would have.


">1/ Whirlwind of Steel. Assuming a human with 23 dex. In the
>context of PvE only. Is impale's -6 dex enough to make "good
>use" (obviously loosely defined) of the Whirlwind of Steel
>legacy? (I understand that ideal situation is 25 dex vs. 3
>dex, but I still want to get a sense whether ~9 or so dex
>differential is sufficient. 9 because I assume mob's average
>baseline dex at 20 + -6 from impale = 14 mob vs. 23 human
>dexterity.) Would love Daev's thoughts on this.

At high levels you probably should assume mobs have more like 25 dex (or overmax to about that point depending on how you want to look at it.)

So really your question is more: is 23 dex vs. 19 dex enough to justify taking this legacy? I'd say no. There's probably about 20 legacies that would do more for you."
[forums.carrionfields.com]

In light of that, I agree with dagger over spear if someone is going with sword for tanking anyway.