Except that I don't think that village is the extreme. Depending how you char sees it, I can totally understand the village dogma. To be honest, I consider outlanders, scarabs and Spire (to some extent) more illogical than villagers (But still I like the cabals all!). Even Fortress is not much better in terms of logical dogma. Actually, I think that Nexus was the most logical one and Empire goes next.
I think same goes for all the cabals: There are a few views on the village, which most of them are well-built and self-consistent enough. But the one which I prefer most, is a self-contradicting one.
p.s.1. I do consider Spire's laws, more illogical than Village's dogma. But Tribunal chars seem to be more IC than villagers.
p.s.2. I understand that you don't like village, and it is totally acceptable/understandable. But again, I don't think that one should call the dogma illogical, but not call other cabals so.