Considering shield cleave has one (successful) outcome and for pk purposes it's equal to or better than the successful + partially successful outcomes of deflect shield you would think it would miss more often, but that hasn't been my experience (of course, because of this observation I don't practice deflect shield anymore, so maybe things have changed).
Either way, my approach until I get get drum, is to main wield a mace and dual wield an axe for shaman and assassins to cleave their shield.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 07/21/2008 12:07PM by ExPaladin.