Hey man, I'm no bastion of RP either. But if you feel like your Imperials are RP bastions..
There's a difference between seeing someone do something stupid and demoting/anathema'ing them. Then, there's this thing where you know this guy could rise atop you and you specifically demote them. One is good Imperial RP, other is being a douche. It's not against the rules, but like I said, let's call a spade a spade.
Also, there are non-douches that play CF. When you were below me in the Black Sect, you talked like you were Dread Lord. You may consider that being assertive and good Imperial, but it's good if you know, that isn't exactly how you act with every other character I've known you to play.
If I were you, I'd just stick to my game knowledge card. You know a shit ton about this game(legit or unlegit). No reason to try to re-write history here, it'll only backfire.