But this new one goes far above and beyond his wants, which apparently weren't satisfied (else I'm misreading the post).
" I posted earlier that some basic preps and questioned why all of the available items lists were weapon/armors, but I never had anything like this in mind. I was hoping for basic scrolls, potions, and wands, but never anything like ABS locations, quest area gear, etc. "
"why all of the available items lists were weapon/armors" - all the lists available are those. He wants some with basic preps.
" was hoping for basic scrolls, potions, and wands" - Which I assume there isn't a list of yet - which I took from his post is because they aren't allowed to be posted/shared as is. Perhaps because his wants over-extend from what is allowed (You sharing one flying thing?)
All I was addressing was that his wants of a list that isn't allowed, their wants of a list that isn't allowed - Are equivalent in that both aren't allowed, so I was hoping he'd elaborate in a response as to why one should be and one shouldn't be.
Assuming what he wants already is allowed and already exists or whatever, then obviously I either misread his post or he misunderstood the rules. Both of which are fine. But my response was as it was because of the post being as it is.
Otherwise I can't say if I agree with the new board or not. I haven't considered it enough. But I still question the legitimacy of the criticism that i've seen so far against it. It's either purely insults or "Just because" (which is what yours falls under since the whole 'quest' info thing). I don't see anything inherently bad with trying to get info if you want info. It's not like it's hurting me or my playtime.
But maybe I'm missing something.